A similar case silhouette or dial color does not establish authenticity. The entries here are historical replica listings and should be understood in that context.
A visual comparison has limits
A matching case outline, dial color or model number does not establish origin. Use photographs to note what is visible and keep authentication separate. Close-ups can help identify differences in layout, but lighting and viewing angle can obscure them.
List comparable fields
Compare the bezel profile, positions of markers, strap attachment and the wording of the reference. If a detail appears only on one listing, it may simply be absent from the other capture. Avoid treating missing images as evidence for or against a claim.
Check provenance independently
A historic replica listing documents what a seller published. It is not provenance for a watch. If the origin of an actual watch matters, consult a qualified independent specialist with access to the physical watch and relevant records.